Futile controversy around new KofC uniform

IMG_5013
My father made his entry in the ranks of the Fourth Degree of the Knights of Columbus in 1978.

Earlier this month, the board of directors of the Knights of Columbus voted for a radical and welcome change to the uniform of the Fourth Degree (the patriotic degree of the Order).

As a member of the Knights of Columbus and its Fourth Degree in his forties, let me tell you why I applaud this long-overdue decision, which is notably based on:

“[…] consistent reports that the old regalia presented a barrier to Fourth Degree membership, especially among younger men.”

I’m one of those people who felt uncomfortable – and let’s admit it – very unhappy with the old regalia. I use the word “old” on purpose.

Historically, Knights of the Patriotic Degree wore their regalia with great pride and purpose. I will always remember with great joy those occasions when my father got ready to dress up with his cape, his beautiful hat and his sword. Ah, the sword, that’s what made us all Catholic boys dream of becoming members of the Fourth Degree when we got older.

But you see, times change. And people too. I became a proud member of the Third Degree right after I turned 18. I got involved, walking in the footsteps of my father. But I always felt itchy about taking the next step. Dressing up like my father no longer appealed to me, because I found it too folkloric and not very humble. How many parish priests did I hear complain the color guard was just too much? How many Brothers of the Third Degree felt uncomfortable to the point of not joining? I know, because I was one of those.

Make no mistake. I have absolutely nothing against history and traditions. As a historian and military buff, I’d be the last guy on the surface of the planet to criticize any form of belonging reflected in uniforms, regalia, medals, etc. The same understanding makes me observe that, over time, uniforms and outfits have changed in different organisations. For example, the British soldiers are no longer dressed as they were during the Seven Years War or the Napoleonic period. The infantrymen of the Civil War era certainly would not recognize the current uniforms of the US servicemen and servicewomen. The same applies to Canadian soldiers, who abandoned the soup bowl looking helmet since World War II.

Of course, there are some who run to the barricades to condemn that change and threaten to quit the ranks. That’s very unfortunate. I don’t need a colourful uniform to show my patriotism. What I need is to be proud, vigorous and consequent with my beliefs. In a true spirit of humility and service. In other words, I don’t need to be dressed like my father was to be committed to the Church, my fellowmen and my country. Such is the true sense of being a member of the Fourth Degree.

Besides, don’t you think that a beret conveys more patriotism than an old fashioned chapeau?

Forgive me saying so in a blunt way, but if you want to quit the ranks because you are unhappy with a decision taken by the chain of command, you might reflect on why is it you joined first?

Correct me if I’m wrong, but nobody changed the basic principles of the Patriotic Degree. They just said “OK, guys, now’s the time to think about the future and the best ways to engage the new generations.”

That’s why I’m comfortable pursuing my involvement in a changing world while always being animated by the same core values. The values my father taught me, those I’m teaching my sons.

Over time, the vast majority of members will salute the visionary leadership of the board of directors’ decision.

Give it time. Blessings are often disguised as wrong turns.

One thought on “Futile controversy around new KofC uniform

  1. I must say that I’m a bit fragmented on the topic of the 4th Degree uniform. I also have been hesitant about moving to the 4th Degree partly because of the flashy cape and chapeau and partly because I am not certain of what joining an Assembly would require of me in terms of time and commitment.
    On the other hand, I certainly do appreciate the distinctive look of the ‘old’ uniform. 4th Degree Knights certainly do stand out and they are the ‘visibly recognized’ part of the order to outsiders. I’m not a huge fan of the new uniform and probably would have preferred some kind of compromise somewhere in between.
    Either way, the decision has been made and we follow.
    P.S. I’m still on the fence with respect to moving to the 4th Degree. 🙂

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s